I saw her at a Bright Eyes show!
5
By SilentZephyr
One of the best Radiohead Covers. When i saw them preform this live, they did a better job than this version they got here. But I recommend it. This is one of the greatest Radiohead songs too.
-f
Rivals the original
5
By Fan77
Not many people could pull this song off, but my god, Gillian Welch has the perfect tourted country voice with a blend of bluegrass and country to make this song into something that would even make Thom Yorke's ears perk up. There will be the Radiohead die-hards that will hate her for even attempting to cover the song, but if you can get past your bias, this song is simply stunning.
cover-city. welch represents in three songs. i love it!
5
By shellymonster
Black star- Amazing cover of a Radiohead song. Not much interference for a live recording, aside from a few choice cheers that I would second. Memorable, emotional, and so melodic it'll make you cry.
Pocahontas- Cover of a Neil Young song; upbeat, does good tribute to the original. I have always wanted to hear this song sung by a woman. I've not been a fan of Cash's interpretation, so this was more up my alley.
White Freightliner Blues-Townes Van Zandt cover. Good energy, upbeat for Welch, brings the album up to complete this lovely 3-song disc. Great string work in this one, pretty fun song.
Don't stop here.. she has so much more you can explore. Enjoy it. It's rare to have a talent so raw but completely new and amazing... as Welch nowadays.
Enjoy!!!
Spellbinding
5
By KazzaM
"Black Star" is one of my FAVORITE covers that Gillian Welch performs (and there are many great songs to chose from in that category....). There is also a cool t-shirt with this EP art that I got from her site.
Nice!
5
By hepcat99
Almost as good as actually seeing them live. Do yourself a favor today and listen to all of it.
Yep, I liked it.
5
By Col. Futrell
This is the best three bucks I've spent on I-Tunes. I've been playing "Black Star" to friends (who usually turn up their noses to anything remotely country sounding) and it's been a big hit. Yeah, I liked the other two as well, but I'm not as music savvy as most and I really can't argue my case. I just liked 'em.
Absolutely gorgeous...
5
By Fab Five Feddy
Until I heard Gillian Welch, I would have thought that only Johnny Cash could sing "Pocahontas" without it sounding cheesy. BOY was I wrong. This EP is wonderful. Black Star is a joy, Pocahontas a revelation and White Freightliner Bluer a bonus. Highly recommended EP. These live EPs are all I have time for - and this one lives up to the bill. Gillian is amazing and this can be for the appreciator or for the novice. It appeals to all. ENJOY it - I know I am.
country smells
1
By Nolikanoli666
willie nelson does not have dread locks!
Pocahontas/Johnny Cash
4
By Ked Z
Just to clarify another review/comment, the Johnny Cash version of Pocahontas is now available in the box set. Just do a search.
Live Cover Songs
2
By Mahdroo
Black Star = Radiohead cover
Pocahontas = Neil Young cover
White Freightliner Blues = Townes Van Zandt cover
Black Star sounds great. I can't stand any other version of Pocahontas since Johnny Cash covered it (a to die for cover his is! sadly not available on i-tunes). And WFB is funny is a Gillian Welch sorta way. The upbeat plucky melody contrasts the lyrics that half of her friends have died. Very charming in her cynical sort of way. Thanks I-tunes and GW for the EP!