Where’s the spirit?
2
By DinostarNM
Probably the most disappointing Christmas album by them. There isn’t much pep or feeling you get from a Xmas album. I really have to ask: why does Scott always sound like he wants to be heard over the other members of the group? Each time someone else is singing his voice always come barging in and the same goes for the music videos — someone will be on screen and you see Scott sliding in like dude, come on, it’s a group thing quit trying to make it about you.
The prayer
4
By AK CV
If that song didn’t melt your heart and make you feel pure joy you aren’t human, have no soul, or have no idea what good music is what a beautiful arrangement
Love it!!
4
By keroberus
I love that they did collab with Lindsey Stirling and Alessia Cara on this album. It's so updated. Not the tired old Christmas songs that have been done again and again. Will always love their sound but I love how they blended so well together on this album--Much more than their usual sound which is recorded separately. I can hear the end result of their mutual input here. (Go watch the YouTube video). To record together is really the most fun part of A'capella. It sounds more mellow, but matured and evolved. My only complaint is the first track was only a minute; it's my absolute favorite oldies song that I never realized could be played as a holiday song, and I wish they had embellished more than a few bars of the Harry James/Kitty Kallen classic.
Wonderful
5
By Dan & Jean
I saw this album performed live when Pentatonix kicked off their Evergreen tour. It is wonderful. The Prayer is beautiful and Over the River is fun.
LOVE
5
By tink6586
been listening to all the songs on repeat, especially love their original Evergreen 🤗
Ugh
1
By James W in Chicago
What a disappointment. PTX almost always delivers but this album really missed the mark.
Jazz?
3
By Rudyrose3
Do not take traditional carols and mess them up
Eh, it’s ok.
3
By xCarrieex
I love PTX, but their last couple of Christmas albums (this one included) haven’t been my favorites. This album in particular feels like it’s missing the same flair and excitement as past ones. The arrangements are missing the classic PTX spin on them or the spins are odd. (Over the River comes to mind for sure.) Sorry guys, but this ain’t it for me. Also, why is “all I want for Christmas” an exclusive track on a physical album? Who has a CD player anymore?
💗💗💗
5
By ALTO.SAX.PLAYER.🎷
ptx can do no wrong and I cry every time I listen to evergreen!! imo the prayer rivals hallelujah for their best xmas arrangement of all time
The Best, Beautiful and Harmonious Album Ever!!!!!
5
By PinkVioletBlue
This is yet another excellent collection of songs. Pentatonix always comes through and never disappoints their fans!
