An early take that is undermixed
3
By LittleWillyWontGo-Go home....
This version proves that Roy Harper wasn't needed and most likely a gimick manufactured by drinking pal Roger Waters at its core.
One of the "Lost" Have a Cigar Out-take Tapes is Here!
5
By Wolfson Mike
This song is in fact one out of the 3 "Lost" out-take tapes that Pink Floyd tried to produce for "Have a Cigar". One of has David Gilmour doing the singing solo, and in another has Roger Waters tried to carry the song solo; and this one is the rarest one of Gilmour/Waters tried to carry it as a "duet act" (That is the one PF has right here) but, all three efforts were proven "not really good enough". Thus, PF did looked for an outside singer...and which they end up with Roy Harper and that was final result on the Wish You Were Here album.
This "Alternate" Have a Cigar does indeed sound vastly different in a general sense, and I do end up enjoy this. You might find this good too. I sure have high hopes that this band will provide some more chances to offer in listen to much more "new material" in the forseenable future for us the PF fans to enjoy pretty much.
Live? Lost studio cut? Wuz up?
4
By KaiKelDev
An alternate version...ok. Where did it come from? Can't find any info about it. I'm a huge fan of the original, but this is a decent change of pace.
Poor rendition to a classic song
2
By MIML
I’m a hug Pink Floyd fan but it’s safe to say this was an unfortunate twist to a classic song.
